Google's Motorola drops key patent claims against Microsoft

Google unit Motorola Mobility has asked a trade panel to drop two key patents from an infringement complaint that it filed against Microsoft, according to a filing at the International Trade Commission.
The ITC has been considering accusations by Motorola Mobility, which has since been purchased by Google, that Microsoft infringed on its patented technology to make its popular Xbox.
Google filed a motion with the ITC on Tuesday, asking that two patents be withdrawn from the case. One patent remains, according to the filing.
The withdrawal was required under an agreement that Google made with the Federal Trade Commission last week settling a pair of long-running antitrust investigations.
The FTC, U.S Department of Justice and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office assert that companies should not request sales bans when filing patent infringement lawsuits based on patents that are essential to a standard in most cases. Standard essential patents ensure that devices are interoperable.
Microsoft identified the two patents withdrawn from the ITC case as standard essential patents.
"We're pleased that Google has finally withdrawn these claims for exclusion orders (sales bans) against Microsoft, and hope that it will now withdraw similar claims pending in other jurisdictions," David Howard, Microsoft's deputy general counsel, said in an emailed statement.
Google did not immediately respond to requests for a comment.
Microsoft said that standard essential patents had been asserted in cases in Wisconsin and Washington district courts, both of which have been stayed. Sales bans, or injunctions, were requested in both cases, Microsoft said.
The ITC is a popular venue for patent lawsuits because it can bar the importation of infringing products and because it issues decisions relatively quickly.
The International Trade Commission case is No. 337-752.
© Thomson Reuters 2012

EU seeks Google accord to address anti-trust concerns

The European Union will seek an accord with US Internet search giant Google as progress has been made in resolving EU anti-trust concerns, EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia said Tuesday.
Almunia said he made the decision after meeting Google head Eric Schmidt in Brussels as "we have substantially reduced our differences regarding possible ways to address" EU competition concerns since talks began in July.
"On the basis of the progress made, I now expect Google to come forward with a detailed commitment text in January 2013," he said in a statement.
This text will used as the basis to firm up the measures Google should take which will "then be market-tested, leading to a possible decision with binding commitments."
The EU listed four areas of concern regarding Google, chief among them how it can highlight links with its own search services in specific areas such as travel or restaurants.
It also has concerns over how Google may use and display third party content on its search services; the possible use of exclusivity agreements by the company and restrictions on allowing advertisers who would want to move their advertising from the company's AdWords service.
The Commission launched an anti-trust investigation into allegations that Google had abused its dominant market position in November 2010.
Tuesday's EU announcement came after reports that US regulators were also likely to conclude a lengthy anti-trust probe into Google's dominance of Internet searches with a voluntary settlement.
The Wall Street Journal said Monday that Google was likely to agree to a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission that calls for unspecified changes in how it handles search queries but would stop short of signing a consent decree that could be enforced by a court.
The Washington Post also reported that a settlement was likely this week, saying it would fall well short of what Google's rivals had sought.
The online news site Politico reported that the FTC did not have the votes to bring an enforcement action against Google but that the settlement would include new practices on the use of "snippets" of user reviews from companies such as Yelp and TripAdvisor, companies which have said Google uses such content without permission.
Politico said Google will also pledge to make it easier for advertisers to buy ad space on its search engine and to move their ad campaigns to competing sites.
Critics say Google controls some 70 percent of the Internet search market and the advertising that goes along with it and may exert even more power in the mobile sector by controlling the Android operating system used on two-thirds of smartphones.
Google has been accused of "scraping" content from other services like travel and restaurant reviews while keeping consumers on its own sites.
It is also under fire for allegedly promoting its own services including travel, restaurant reviews and YouTube videos in its search results.